How Pancho Villa Turned to the Pen in Lecumberri Prison

Villa's time in the bleak Lecumberri Prison—known as the “Black Palace”—could have been a dark chapter lost in the annals of history. But it turned into a transformative period for the legendary revolutionary. On the brink of execution, Villa found an unexpected ally behind bars.

How Pancho Villa Turned to the Pen in Lecumberri Prison
Villa and a group of Dorados surrender arms in Sabinas, undated. Credit: AGN

When we think of Pancho Villa, the flamboyant Mexican revolutionary general, we often picture a man on horseback, leading his troops through the rugged terrains of Northern Mexico. Known as the “Centaur of the North,” Villa's larger-than-life persona frequently overshadows the lesser-known chapters of his turbulent life.

One such period is his controversial imprisonment in Lecumberri Prison in 1912. Beneath the legend lies a more nuanced story—of false accusations, his time behind bars, and the remarkable legal efforts that aimed to set him free. Let's dive in, shall we?

The Arrest Heard Around Mexico

On June 5, 1912, El Tiempo, a leading Mexican newspaper at the time, ran a front-page story: “Francisco Villa is brought to this capital to be tried.” The arrest followed a clash between Villa's forces and those led by Antonio Rábago, under orders from General Victoriano Huerta. For those unacquainted with Mexican history, Huerta was the chief of the Federal Army battling the insurgency led by Pascual Orozco against the government of Francisco I. Madero.

And the reason for Villa's arrest? Bizarrely enough, it began over a horse—a thoroughbred mare, to be precise. A federal officer seized the horse, irritating Villa, which led to a heated argument with Huerta. This disagreement escalated into accusations of insubordination against Villa.

The argument had serious consequences. Villa was not just arrested; he was taken before a firing squad. But just as the execution was about to proceed, it was interrupted—multiple times. General Francisco Castro eventually ordered the squad to stand down and sent Villa on a train to Mexico City. Speculation abounds as to why the execution was halted. Some theories suggest intervention by brothers Raul and Emilio Madero, or even a direct order from President Madero himself.

The Black Palace of Lecumberri

Upon arriving in Mexico City, Villa was thrust into the bleak conditions of Lecumberri Prison, infamously known as the “Black Palace.” Here, he awaited his trial in a dark, poorly ventilated cell, isolated from other inmates. While initially accused of insubordination and disobedience, the charges against him mysteriously multiplied to include robbery and looting.

While in prison, Villa met Zapatista colonel Gildardo Magaña, a fellow inmate who was also caught in political turbulence. They discussed their shared goals and even considered an escape plan, although Villa ultimately decided against it, trusting that President Madero would secure their release.

During this period, Villa also took the opportunity to educate himself. He worked on improving his spelling and writing skills, perhaps realizing the power of the pen could be as mighty as the sword. He penned multiple letters to President Madero, pleading for an audience and seeking justice.

Enter Antonio Méndez Castellanos, a lawyer who generously offered to take up Villa's case at no cost. Castellanos began a fervent letter-writing campaign, defending Villa's military service under Madero and critiquing the lack of evidence for the new charges levied against him.

After much legal wrangling and negotiations, Villa was transferred out of Lecumberri to Santiago Tlatelolco, a military prison, in November 1912. A month later, he escaped.

A Time of Growth Amid Darkness

Villa's time in Lecumberri was undoubtedly one of the most trying periods of his life. Yet, this phase was not merely a bleak interruption in his revolutionary journey; it was also a transformative period. Behind bars, Villa found solace in books, sharpened his writing skills, and laid the foundation for a new chapter in his life. One that would see him return to the battlefield with not just guns, but also a newfound appreciation for the power of words.

In the complex mosaic that is Pancho Villa's life, his Lecumberri imprisonment serves as a crucial yet often overlooked tile. It adds not just color but depth, reminding us that even heroes have their vulnerable moments, and occasionally, it's those moments that make them are truly extraordinary.

Journalistic note “Francisco Villa is brought to this capital to be tried”, Mexico, June 5, 1912.
Journalistic note “Francisco Villa is brought to this capital to be tried”, Mexico, June 5, 1912, in AGN, Biblioteca-Hemeroteca Ignacio Cubas, El Tiempo, Mexico City, year XXIX, no. 9506.
Men executed on the wall, undated.
Men executed on the wall, undated, AGN, Archivos Fotográficos, Enrique Díaz, Delgado y García, box 1-7.
Francisco Villa standing next to a railroad engine, 1912.
Francisco Villa standing next to a railroad engine, 1912, AGN, Photographic Archives, Artistic and Literary Property, La Rochester. Revolución/35, box 17, PAL- 2675.
Colonel Francisco Villa with his machine gun and a group of revolutionaries, 1912.
Colonel Francisco Villa with his machine gun and a group of revolutionaries, 1912, AGN, Archivos Fotográficos, Enrique Díaz, Delgado y García, box 1-7.
Petition for pardon for General Francisco Villa by Antonio Méndez Castellanos, October 1, 1912.
Petition for pardon for General Francisco Villa by Antonio Méndez Castellanos, October 1, 1912, in AGN, México Contemporáneo, Archivos Presidenciales, Fco. I Madero, box 009, exp. 222-1.
Manifesto of Antonio Méndez Castellanos to Nemesio García Naranjo, director of the newspaper La Tribuna.
Manifesto of Antonio Méndez Castellanos to Nemesio García Naranjo, director of the newspaper La Tribuna, October 20, 1912, in AGN, México Contemporáneo, Archivos Presidenciales, Fco. I Madero, box 009, exp. 222-1.
Official letter from Deputy Juan Sánchez Azcona, private secretary of President Madero.
Official letter from Deputy Juan Sánchez Azcona, private secretary of President Madero, informing Antonio Méndez Castellanos about the transfer of Francisco Villa to the prison of Santiago, November 7, 1912, in AGN, México Contemporáneo, Presidential Archives, Fco. I Madero, box 034, exp. 220-3.
Portrait of Francisco Villa, 1911.
Portrait of Francisco Villa, 1911, AGN, Photographic Archives, Artistic and Literary Property, H. J. Gutiérrez-Revolución-97, box 10, PAL-1482.

Source: Archivo General de la Nación (2023, August 3). El encierro de Pancho Villa, una historia escrita en Lecumberri. Gobierno de México. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://www.gob.mx/agn/articulos/el-encierro-de-pancho-villa-una-historia-escrita-en-lecumberri?idiom=es